By Gordon Anderson | gordon@rantnc.com

Following the discovery of what was called a “procedural inconsistency,” the Lee County Board of Commissioners voted unanimously on Monday to readopt its Unified Development Ordinance as well as language regulating the construction of data centers.

Sanford-Lee County Planning Director Marshall Downey told the commissioners on Monday that staff had discovered “that we had not followed our prescribed process” in adopting several years worth of UDO text amendments, namely that “the governing board shall approve a brief statement describing whether the action is consistent or inconsistent with our comprehensive land use plan.” The UDO is a document adopted by Lee County, Sanford and Broadway and governs development in all three jurisdictions.

Dwight McCarly, an attorney retained by the county for advice on the matter, said his opinion was that any UDO language adopted more than three years and one day ago “is safe,” due to a statute of limitations. But anything more recent than that – including a site plan and a permit for a controversial data center project – “in my opinion, is subject to challenge.”

McCarly said that could create issues, specifically for the data center project, because the board’s previously adopted data center regulations could be made void by a successful challenge. That would leave the county without any data center restrictions and force planners to “look for the most nearly comparable item, using industrial codes, and cite it in the zones that that would be allowed in,” McCarly said.

“The problem with that,” he continued, “is that you have a valid zone at the current site proposed for the data center that is light industrial. You would then have a legitimate site, and free use of property would say that the court would say ‘they can go there.’ But, there would be no rules. It would be a free for all for the developer of the data center to do whatever they wanted as long as they met the minimal regulations for that zone.”

Attorney Dwight McCarly addresses the Lee County Board of Commissioners on Monday.

The Lee County Planning Board recommended readoption of the UDO with the necessary consistency statements on November 9.

Opponents of the data center project saw the situation as an opening to renew calls for a data center moratorium, arguing that it was an opportunity to revisit – and strengthen – the data center regulations the board adopted in the spring.

“If you notice a hearing tomorrow, you can have a 60-day moratorium in place before Thanksgiving,” said Cliff Robbins, an attorney for the Southern Coalition for Social Justice.

Robbins said that given recent statements by board members about openness to looking at stricter regulations for future data centers, the board is in “a different, and better position today than it was a month ago.”

“Now the commission has legal grounds and ability to, for the first time, lawfully enact data center regulations,” he said.

McCarly said the public hearing was advertised as having a narrow purpose, and the board’s action should match it.

“The goal tonight is to consider a consistency statement for the UDO and to ratify and readopt the UDO,” he said. “Not to make changes, not amendments – none of those have been proposed or advertised or put before you. It is simply to look at a consistency statement to fix the procedural error that was made by not having consistency statements for text amendments in the past.”

The board readopted the UDO in a series of unanimous votes following the public hearing. Democratic Commissioner Cameron Sharpe was absent.

Prior to the vote, County Attorney Whitney Parrish asked whether any board members had a conflict of interest on the issue. Republican Commissioner Kirk Smith replied that “none of us have taken any envelopes under the table.”

Monday’s meeting was the last with the Board of Commissioners as currently constituted. Republican member Eric Davidson was defeated in the November election by Democrat Jamey Laudate, who will take office in December and create a 4-3 Democratic majority. The board passed a resolution honoring Davidson’s service on Monday night.

The Sanford City Council and the Broadway Town Board are scheduled to consider readoption of the Unified Development Ordinance at meetings in November.